Autism & ABA- Irish Education Minister Spins Old, Flawed Argument
Minister for Education & Science, Mary Hanafin T.D.
In reading news today from Ireland I had a strong sense of deja vu. Irish Education Minister Mary Hanafin persists in rejecting calls for ABA based education for Irish students with autism. Her argument? There are several suitable forms of education that are available in Ireland. The article does not provide any quotes or indications of what these several suitable forms might be and the Minister was criticized by a professional member of her own government’s autism task force. In New Brunswick our Department of Education used similar arguments for several years to resist provision of ABA based education for autistic students for several years. ABA is heavily documented as an effective evidence based approach to educating students with autism. The mysterious “several suitable forms” other than ABA have yet to be documented.
The Minister for Education is coming under fire from a leading expert over her approach to dealing with autism.
Minister Mary Hanafin has repeatedly rejected calls from parents for the introduction of the expensive Applied Behavioural Analysis method for teaching autistic children.
Doctors say it is the most effective method, but Ms Hanafin is continuing to insist that there are several suitable forms of education that are available in Ireland.
Dr Rita Honan, a member of the department’s own task force on autism, has now come out and said that the approach advocated by Ms Hanafin has no scientific basis and ABA has been proven to be more successful than any other teaching programme.
She also says the minister’s stance makes no financial sense as the expensive ABA programme can lead to substantial savings in the long run.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/breaking-news/ireland/article2528459.ece
-
Archives
- June 2007 (7)
- May 2007 (51)
- April 2007 (40)
- March 2007 (40)
- February 2007 (41)
- January 2007 (26)
- December 2006 (24)
- November 2006 (21)
- October 2006 (25)
- September 2006 (22)
- August 2006 (10)
-
Categories
- 108th District
- A Perfectly Cromulent Blog
- aba
- ABAA
- About Autism
- abuse
- activism
- ADHD
- adult autism
- adult care
- adult residential care
- advocacy
- African American Community
- Alberta
- Amanda J Sampson
- anaheim ducks
- Andrew Wakefield
- Andy Scott
- anecdotal evidence
- Applied Behavior Analysis
- applied behavioral analysis
- applied behaviour analysis
- Applied Behavioural Analysis
- ASNB
- Asperger Disorder
- Asperger Syndrome
- Aspergers' Syndrome
- Assemblymember Tim Gordon
- Athletes Against Autism
- Atlantic Behavioural Centre
- Atlantica
- Aubrey's Journey
- auism disorder
- Auism Vox
- auitsm disorder
- Australia
- autism
- autism advocacy
- autism awareness
- autism awareness month
- autism awarenss
- autism awarness
- autism causes
- autism challenges
- autism community training
- Autism Connections Fredericton
- autism crisis
- autism cure
- autism diagnosis
- autism disorder
- Autism Early Intervention Outcomes Unit
- autism education
- autism entertainment
- autism ethics
- autism every day
- autism genome
- Autism Genome Project
- autism health
- Autism Intervention Services
- autism interventions
- Autism Knowledge Revolution
- autism prevalence
- Autism Pro
- autism protest
- autism rates
- autism reality
- Autism Report
- autism research
- autism residential care
- autism resource center
- autism resource centre
- Autism Society America
- Autism Society Canada
- Autism Society New Brunswick
- autism speaks
- Autism Speaks 400
- autism spectrum disorder
- autism spectrum disorders
- autism support workers
- autism therapy
- autism treatment
- autistic
- Baron-Cohen
- behavior
- behavior management
- behavioral intervention
- behavioral seizure
- behavioural intervention
- Bernard
- Better Focus on Autism Now Act of 2007
- bigfoot
- Bill C-304
- Bill Cosby
- biomedical
- birthday
- bledsoe
- bloc quebecois
- blogger
- blogging
- blogs
- Bob Wright
- book
- books
- Brian Murphy
- budget
- budget 2007
- bureaucracy
- c-304
- CAIRN
- cake
- calming
- campaign promises
- Canada Health Act
- Canadian Human Rights Tribunal
- Canadian Senate
- Capital Times
- casein
- causes
- CBC
- CDC
- Charles LeBlanc
- chatham public library
- chelation
- Chicago Tribune
- child corruption
- Children's Aid
- choice
- CIHR
- civility
- CNN
- coffee
- Combating Autism Act
- commitment
- community groups
- computer
- Conor
- Conor Doherty
- Conservative Party
- conservatives
- credibility
- Crown Royal
- Cure Autism Now
- D. L. Clarke
- Dad
- Daily Gleaner
- Dalton McGuinty
- DAN
- DAN Protocol
- David Kirby
- David Royko
- Deborarh Pugh
- Desking
- developmental delay
- diagnosis
- diet
- diptheria
- Dirty Tricks
- disability
- discrimination
- doherty
- Don Imus
- Dover International Speedway
- Dr. Gupta
- Dr. James Morton
- Dr. King
- Dr. Larry Needham
- Dr. Sanja Gupta
- Dr. Seuss
- Dr. Sheila Laredi
- Dr. Stanley Greenspan
- Dr. Theresa McKenzie
- DSM-IV
- early intervention
- education
- Education Minister Kelly Lamrock
- Education Minister Lamrock
- eduction
- eibi
- election
- election promise
- election promises
- emotional
- employment
- environment
- environmental sensitivity
- Eric Fombonne
- Erik Lykke Mortensen
- evidence based
- evidence based interventions
- evidence based treatment
- evidence of harm
- excited delirium syndrome
- Expanding the Promise
- faces of autism
- family
- family stress
- fashion
- FEAT
- FEAT BC
- federal budget
- flu
- Fredericton
- fun
- funding
- funding cuts
- Garth Turner
- Geier
- genetics
- GFCF diet
- Gilles Duceppe
- Globe and Mail
- gluten
- goody bledsoe
- govenrment
- government
- Green Eggs and Ham
- Gulf Times
- Halifax
- happy
- Harchik
- HB 1224
- HBOT
- health
- health care
- heather doherty
- heather doherty writes
- Henteleff
- hepatitis
- high funcitioning autism
- high functioning autism
- Hillary Clinton
- honor
- hospital
- Human Rights
- hyperbaric oxygen treatment
- Hyperbarid Oxygen Treatment
- hypocrisy
- ibi
- Inc.
- inclusion
- international cooperation
- internet
- intervention
- interventions
- IQ
- Ireland
- Irish Autism Action
- Jack Layton
- jail
- Jamie McMurray
- Jean Lewis
- Jennifer J Couper
- Jim Munson
- Jim Sinclair
- Jim Young
- John Foran
- John Hopkins University
- John Tuman
- Joseph J. Roberts
- Journal Standard
- joy
- Joy of Conor
- Judy Wasylycia-Leis
- jurisdiction
- Kaiser Permanente
- Kathleen Wynne
- Katie Couric
- Kelly Lamrock
- Kennedy
- Key Art Awards
- Kings Place
- Kristina Chew
- Lana Thomson
- Lars Smith
- laughing
- Laurnet Mottron
- law enforcement
- learning
- Lee Scott
- legislation
- Liberal Party
- lila barry
- Lisa Jo Rudy
- Lisal Jo Rudy
- literature
- Lovaas
- low functioning autism
- Lyme Disease
- Mackay
- Madison
- MADSEC
- Maine
- mainstreaming
- Mark De Silvo
- Mary Hanafin
- maternal age
- math
- May Institute
- measles
- medicare
- meningitis
- mercury
- Michael Wagnitz
- Michelle Dawson
- Michelle Muntean
- Mike Lake
- minocycline
- MMR
- Monte Solberg
- mumps
- Nashwaaksis
- national autim strategy
- national autism strategy
- National Autistic Society
- natural beauty
- natural variation
- NBACL
- NBC
- NDP
- neurodiversity
- neuroinflammation
- Nevada
- New Brunswick
- New Brunswick Association for Community Living
- new jersey
- New York
- New York State Assembly
- New York Times
- Nils Kaland
- Nimal Mendis
- noise
- non-social cognitive tasks
- nose
- Nova Scotia
- oberon press
- Olie Kolzig
- Ontario
- Open Every Door
- Oprah
- ottawa senators
- oxytocin
- parents
- paternal age
- Paul McDonnell
- PBS Kids
- PDD-NOS
- pediatricians
- penny
- Peter McMartin
- Peter Stoffer
- philosophy
- photos
- political correctness
- politics
- Portia Iversen
- prediction
- Premier Graham
- Premier Shawn Graham
- prevalence
- Prime Minister Harper
- Psychiatric Times
- psychology
- puberty
- public health
- Qatar
- Quebec
- Rally
- reading
- recreation
- research
- Research Autism
- residential care
- resource teachers
- ritalin
- Rob Corddry
- Robert Kennedy Jr.
- Robinson
- Roy Grinker
- rubella
- Saint John River
- Saint Patrick's Day
- Saskatchewan
- Scherer
- schools
- scientific
- screaming
- Second Cup
- senate
- Senate Autism Report
- severe autism
- Shawn Graham
- Shawn Murphy
- shdopkpd
- Sheniz Moonie
- signs of autism
- snow
- special needs
- Special Needs Network
- speech
- Spurwink
- standards
- stanley cup
- Stephane Dion
- Stephen Harper
- Stewart Paul
- Strange Son
- sundance film festival
- Supreme Court of Canada
- Suzanne Wright
- Szatmari
- TA's
- TAAP
- tantrum behavior
- tasers
- teacher assistants
- teachers
- teachers aides
- technology
- Telegraph Journal
- Texas
- The Cat in the Hat
- The Daily Show
- the rain man
- the view
- therapy
- thimerosal
- Throne Speech
- Tobique-Mactaquac
- Today Show
- Toni Braxton
- Tony Blair
- Tony Clement
- Tony Huntjens
- Toronto Star
- training
- treatment
- UCLA
- UN-CEL
- UNB-CEL
- UNB-CEL Autism Intervention Training Program
- Uncategorized
- United Kingdom
- vaccinations
- vaccines
- valentine card
- Vancouver Province
- vancouver sun
- VISA
- Wagnitz
- walk now for autism
- walking trail
- Wayne MacKay
- whooping cough
- Wikipedia
- woodstock
- Wynberg
- Yes I Can
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS